I was having a debate with some friends about how “becoming an expert at something requires focus and single-mindedness on the subject matter“. My position in the debate was that I want my sons (now 1 and 2.5 in age) to be “supremely excellent” at something (music, sports, academics… whatever). I drew some contention when I said that I will not allow my boys to engage in more than one activity at a time. If they want to play sports, then that means no music lessons, etc. My colleague mentioned that this will stifle the polymathic potential in my boys (a polymath is a person of wide-ranging knowledge or learning – like Einstein). The debate eventually fizzled, but I left feeling a little unjustified. Today it hit me; the point I was trying to convey (unsuccessfully) was the 10,000 hour rule, and how as a father, I will do my best to see my boys reach that mark.
The 10,000 hour rule was made famous by Malcom Gladwell in his book “Outliers”. Gladwell repeatedly mentions the “10,000-Hour Rule”, claiming that the key to success in any field is, to a large extent, a matter of practicing a specific task for a total of around 10,000 hours.
The rule was originally based on a study by Anders Ericsson. Gladwell (via Ericsson) claims that greatness requires enormous time, and the key to success in any field, is simply a matter of practicing a specific task that can be accomplished with 20 hours of work a week, for 10 years (reaching the 10,000-Hour mark). Gladwell refers to Bill Gates as an example of this: “Gates met the 10,000-Hour Rule when he gained access to a high school computer in 1968 at the age of 13, and spent 10,000 hours programming on it.”
I went to the actual study by Ericsson, and I found it really interesting… here are some excerpts:
Not magic, or genetics, or superiority – but practice and training:
When experts exhibit their superior performance in public their behavior looks so effortless and natural that we are tempted to attribute it to special talents. Although a certain amount of knowledge and training seems necessary, the role of acquired skill for the highest levels of achievement has traditionally been minimized. However, when scientists began measuring the experts’ supposedly superior powers of speed, memory and intelligence with psychometric tests, no general superiority was found –the demonstrated superiority was domain specific. For example, the superiority of the chess experts’ memory was constrained to regular chess positions and did not generalize to other types of materials. Not even IQ could distinguish the best among chess players nor the most successful and creative among artists and scientists.
New Patterns from memory:
In their influential theory of expertise, Chase and Simon proposed that experts with extended experience acquire a larger number of more complex patterns and use these new patterns to store knowledge about which actions should be taken in similar situations.
According to this influential theory, expert performance is viewed as an extreme case of skill acquisition…
Extended experience:
Among investigators of expertise, it has generally been assumed that the performance of experts improved as a direct function of increases in their knowledge through training and extended experience.
In summary:
In a recent review, Ericsson and Lehmann found that (1) measures of general basic capacities do not predict success in a domain, (2) the superior performance of experts is often very domain specific and transfer outside their narrow area of expertise is surprisingly limited and (3) systematic differences between experts and less proficient individuals nearly always reflect attributes acquired by the experts during their lengthy training.
I want my boys to be supremely awesome! But I don’t want to be an over-bearing or fanatical father. I guess the challenge is to help them discover their passion and then guide and enable them to get to at-least 10,000 hours of engagement in that passion.
How we do all of this will take cooperation and coordination between my wife and I. But ultimately we need to be on the same page, and this post is my first attempt to doing so.
What do you think? Any advice? cries of outrage?







RSS feed for comments on this post. / TrackBack URI